Are you falling for LinkedIn's biggest lie?

The shocking truth about engagement metrics (and what really matters)

Read time: 4 minutes

Picture this:

You've just posted on LinkedIn. Your phone buzzes with notifications.

Reactions. Comments. Reposts.

Your dopamine spikes. You feel on top of the world.

But wait...

Is this success? Or are you falling for LinkedIn's biggest lie?

Today, we're pulling back the curtain on a truth that might make you uncomfortable:

Those engagement metrics you're chasing? They're often nothing more than a mirage.

Let's dive in and discover what matters most for you and your business on LinkedIn.

Stop The Engagement Illusion

LinkedIn, like all social media platforms, has mastered the art of keeping us hooked. They've gamified our professional lives. They've turned our business activities into a quest for reactions, comments, and reposts.

But here's the uncomfortable truth:

These are nothing more than vanity metrics.

They're designed to keep you scrolling, posting, and engaging... but often at the expense of real business growth.

Let's break it down:

The Vanity Metrics Trap

Engagement on your recent post explodes…

  • 1000+ reaction

  • 500+ comments

  • 100k impressions

Sounds impressive, right? But what does it mean for your business?

Often, not much.

These numbers might make you feel good, but they don't pay the bills. They don't bring in clients. They don't solve real business problems.

What Matters Most

Instead of chasing reactions, focus on:

  • Building industry authority

  • Generating tangible results

  • Attracting qualified leads

  • Converting connections into paying clients

These are the metrics that move the needle for your business.

The Science Behind the Addiction

You might be thinking, "But Ryan, if these metrics don't matter, why do I care so much?"

Great question! Let's dive into some psychology.

The Dopamine Loop

If you're posting regularly on LinkedIn, then you're no stranger to notifications like these...

  • "Ryan and 21 others reacted to your post"

  • "Alice replied to your comment"

  • "Joe commented on your post"

Every time you get these notifications your brain releases a small dose of dopamine. This hormone, a neurotransmitter, makes you feel pleasure and reward. It gives you a feeling of satisfaction.

But here's the truth: Your brain soon adapts to this level of stimulation. So you need more and more engagement to get the same "high."

This is exactly how addictions form.

The Variable Reward Schedule

Social media platforms use what psychologists call a "variable reward schedule." This is the same principle that makes slot machines so addictive.

You never know when you'll get your next "reward" (reaction, comment, repost). So what do you do? You keep coming back to check. It's unpredictable, and that's what makes it so compelling.

Breaking Free

So, how can you break free from this addictive cycle and focus on real business growth? Here are some strategies that I use:

1. Redefine Your Metrics

Instead of tracking reactions and comments, track:

  • Number of meaningful conversations started

  • Qualified leads generated

  • Connection requests sent

  • Meetings scheduled

  • Clients gained.

These are the metrics that impact your bottom line. They either get conversations started with the right people or turn those conversations into clients.

2. Quality Over Quantity

It's better to have 10 deep, meaningful interactions than 1000 surface-level engagements. So focus on creating content that sparks real conversations and connections.

3. Solve Real Problems

Use your LinkedIn presence to address actual pain points that your ideal clients face. When you're helpful, you attract the right kind of attention. You attract attention from people who need help from you.

4. Build Authentic Relationships

Networking isn't about collecting connections. It's about forming genuine professional relationships. Invest time in getting to know your connections on a deeper level.

5. Leverage the "Mere Exposure Effect"

We all develop preferences for things because we're familiar with them. That's the mere exposure effect in a nutshell. So on Linkedin, this means consistently showing up. It means sharing valuable content on a regular basis, setting time aside to engage, and interacting with your ideal clients.

But don't make the mistake of biting off more than you can chew.

  • If you only have 30 minutes a day, then that's fine.

  • If you can't post every day, then post every other day.

Be consistent on a timescale that suits you. Just because someone else spends hours every day on Linkedin, it doesn't mean you need to too. As long as you are intentional and are setting some time aside at regular intervals, then that's what counts.

Over time, this consistent presence helps you build trust and recognition with others. They start noticing you, paying attention, and they get curious about what you have to offer them.

A Tale of Two LinkedIn Users

Let me illustrate this with a story:

Meet Sarah and Joe, both consultants in the same field.

The one obsessed with their engagement metrics? That's Sarah. She spends hours crafting "viral" posts, always chasing that next big hit. Her follower count is impressive, and her posts often get hundreds of likes.

Joe, on the other hand, focuses on providing genuine value. His posts might not get as many reactions, but they spark meaningful conversations. He regularly turns these conversations into enquiries, which often lead to new clients.

After a year, Sarah has an impressive LinkedIn profile with lots of vanity metrics. But she's struggling to pay the bills.

Joe’s metrics might not look as flashy. But his business is thriving, with a steady stream of high-quality clients.

The difference? Joe understood that real success on LinkedIn isn't about reactions and comments. It's about genuine connections and real-world results.

Moral of the story:

Don't let LinkedIn's gamification fool you. You're not here to win internet points. You're here to build a thriving business.

Next time you find yourself fixated on those engagement metrics, pause and ask yourself:

"Is this really what I want? Or am I just addicted to the game?"

Remember: You're building a business, not chasing reactions. Focus on what matters the most,

The rest? It's just noise.

And on that note, here's a quote for you to ponder:

We buy things we don't need with money we don't have to impress people we don't like.

Dave Ramsey

Replace "buy things" with "chase engagement," and you've got a perfect description of the LinkedIn rat race.

Don't fall for it. You're better than that.

Until next week,

Ryan

Reply

or to participate.